
TV
News Makes Me Sick!
February
25, 2004
by Editor Lynn Nichols
When
I was in college in the mid-1970s (OK, I'm that old), one
of my professors introduced our class to a terrific book.
It's called News from Nowhere, by Edward Jay
Epstein. The premise was simple. TV news is a manufactured
product, and its aim is not to inform, but to induce
viewers to "stay tuned." At the time, I didn't
believe it.
Now
just to let you know up front, I graduated from Emerson
College with a degree in Mass Communications. Yep, I
actually thought, back in my naïve 20s, that I would like
to have a career in TV news. So I studied really hard,
assistant produced the news on the college TV station,
read lots of Marshall McLuhan and idolized Eric Severid,
Walter Cronkite and Barbara Walters.
Then
I graduated and joined the unemployment line with the rest
of my class. After hundreds of resumes sent and about
sixty rejections received (with which I actually
considering wallpapering my room), I decided that
television production wasn't for me. So I took a job in
publishing, a move that became a 20-year career.
Over
the years that followed my college graduation, I was
jealous of the newscasters on TV. Jealous of my classmates
at Emerson who had "made it." I thought of the
big salary I could be making if I was only an anchorwoman,
or a producer, or an assistant producer, or the girl who
gets the coffee. Looking back on it now, it seems kind of
pathetic.
As
I got more wrapped up in the publishing world, I
eventually lost my desire to work in TV news. And movies
like Network and Broadcast News confirmed my
decision not to pursue TV news as a career. But I always
watched the news programs, and was particularly happy when
the new cable news outlets started up. News 24 hours a
day! For a news junkie like me, that was an exciting
promise.
At
first, CNN, Headline News and then MSNBC offered some
promise. CNN brought us the first Iraq war, live from
Baghdad. Though I didn't agree with the war, I had to
admit that the coverage was impressive. I started to tire
a little with the Monica Lewinsky affair and subsequent
impeachment (All Monica All the Time). But by the time the
2000 election rolled around, I was getting really miffed.
Why did the news seem less like news and more like
entertainment to me?
When
Ted Turner quit AOL/Time Warner (owners of CNN) citing
differences in opinion with the direction the station was
taking, the handwriting was on the wall in big capital
letters. NEWS IS ENTERTAINMENT!! It doesn't matter what's
happening in the economy, or the environment, or in life
as real people live it -- it only matters what's happening
with celebrities!
As
far as CNN and MSNBC go (or right wing Fox for that
matter), forget anything that happens outside U.S.
borders. Canada? They're just a bunch of loonies to our
north. Mexico? Central and South America? Are we really
part of the same continent? Europe? Do those Europeans
ever do anything important? Not according to the U.S.
news, they don't.
Sure,
we hear about the occasional bombing in Bali and
earthquake in Iran. Terrorist attacks and natural
disasters are always good journalism, especially if
there's some really exciting film footage to go with it.
But if there's a one second "wardrobe
malfunction" at the Super Bowl or a celebrity dangles
a baby over a crocodile's jaws or out an open window,
that's got to take precedence. Now that's NEWS.
Then,
of course, there's the news media's inability to let go of
a story, even after it's played out. A good case in point
is the "Dean Scream." Two weeks after the Iowa
caucuses, some TV "journalists" were still
trying to use that one moment in time to define the entire
man. In fact, the "I have a scream" speech
played more than 600 times on CNN alone! I may be cynical,
but to my mind that shows a deliberate attempt to quell
the rise of a "outsider" candidate. In fact, it
probably cost him the nomination. And whom do we get
instead? That media darling, our wooden, "war
hero" junior senator (but don't get me started on JK).
So
where do I get my news from these days? The only
television news worth watching in on C-SPAN 1, the House
of Representatives channel. Their morning Washington
Journal program discusses issues in a calm considered
manner. No shouting, so dueling pundits, just responsible
reporting and phone calls from viewers (who are also very
considerate). In my humble opinion, everything else on TV
that's labelled "news," whether it's on network
or cable, is pure hogwash.
Most
of the time, however, I get my news from the alternative
press through e-mail newsletters and websites, including
TruthOut.org, AlterNet.org, TomPaine.com, TrueMajority.com
and Jim Hightower's "Lowdown." If you haven't
done so before, check the links in the Alternative Media
Watch column below to find out what's really going on in
this country.
From
this moment on, I'm declaring my independence from TV
news. As the fictional news anchor from the movie Network
once said, "I want you to go to your windows, throw
out your television, and scream 'I'm mad as hell, and I'm
not going to take it anymore!"
Couldn't
have said it better myself.
(Back
to Viewpoints)
|